January 26, 2021 | The National Interest
Why “Anything But Trump” Should Not Be Biden’s Foreign Policy Mantra
Trump made many errors, but there are some policies that are worth building upon.
January 26, 2021 | The National Interest
Why “Anything But Trump” Should Not Be Biden’s Foreign Policy Mantra
Trump made many errors, but there are some policies that are worth building upon.
Getting the incoming administration of President Joe Biden to acknowledge Donald Trump’s foreign policy accomplishments was always going to be an uphill battle. In part, that’s just par for the course. Especially since the end of the Cold War, a pattern has developed by which presidents of the opposing party tend to look askance at anything their immediate predecessor did. With Trump, of course, that partisan impulse has been super-charged by four years of serial abominations by an unchained narcissist. His outrages, large and small. The incessant norm shattering. The sheer lack of basic decency.
And all that was before Trump devoted the final months of his term to a frequently delusional, but always dangerous assault on America’s constitutional order—culminating in the shocking spectacle of the President of the United States stoking a frenzied mob to violently storm the seat of American democracy and attack a co-equal branch of government in his name. Against that backdrop, if the Biden team’s instinct to recoil from Trump’s legacy was already strong before January 6, 2021, it was probably damn near overwhelming afterwards.
We get it. But as the co-editors of a just-published collection of twenty-five essays assessing Trump’s record on a range of critical national security issues, we’ve also concluded that adopting some version of ABT, or “Anything But Trump,” would be a serious mistake. While the contributors to From Trump to Biden: The Way Forward For U.S. National Security collectively found no shortage of areas where Trumpism abroad, otherwise known as “America First,” stumbled or outright failed, they also identified a number of his administration’s policies that advanced important U.S. national interests, and are worthy of being built upon.
Trump’s foreign policy deficiencies are no doubt well known to Biden and require little elaboration here. Even a partial list is long: The gratuitous insults of longstanding democratic allies and questioning of solemn treaty commitments. The flattery of tyrants and disregard for human rights. The sudden and irresponsible withdrawal of troops from key military theaters. An oftentimes shambolic decision-making process marked by chaos, flip flops, and deep contradictions between Trump and his top advisors.
Harder to acknowledge for the Biden team—though new Secretary of State Antony Blinken made an admirable effort in his confirmation hearing—will be Trump’s successes, and those areas where his administration’s policies have left the United States better positioned to secure its interests. Three of the outgoing administration’s achievements, in particular, deserve highlighting—at least in part because they represent sharp breaks from the policies of the Obama administration, in which Biden and most of his top advisors played such central roles.