December 12, 2023 | Commentary
After Hamas is destroyed, here are the five things that must not happen in Gaza
December 12, 2023 | Commentary
After Hamas is destroyed, here are the five things that must not happen in Gaza
Excerpt
Israel is resolved to remove Hamas and its terrorist infrastructure from the Gaza Strip permanently, and for much of the world, its determination raises one question more than any other: What comes next in Gaza? For those who disapprove of Israel’s actions in the war or those who either passively or actively support the role of Hamas as the Strip’s governing authority, the lack of answers provides a pretext not only to demand a permanent cease-fire but to suggest (often quietly and with a furrowed brow indicating supposed realpolitik wisdom) that the path Israel seems to be making for itself is a dead end from which it needs to be saved.
For the Arab world, the vacuum creates a jockeying for power and influence, albeit behind the scenes to avoid accountability for anything that goes wrong.
For the Biden administration, this has invited fantasies of a renewed path to an ever-elusive two-state solution—a Palestinian Authority governing a unified West Bank and Gaza, and supposedly representing the views of all Palestinians in negotiations with Israel. Big ideas for Gaza’s future are being cooked up behind closed doors in Washington. Task forces and blue-ribbon commissions are sure to follow. But allowing the Washington establishment to paint a foreign policy on a blank canvas, mapping the relations between Israel and the Arabs surrounding it, is a risky proposition that will, as it always has in the past, fail.
This article will be featured in the January 2024 edition of Commentary.
Richard Goldberg is a senior adviser at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies. He has served on Capitol Hill, on the U.S. National Security Council, as the Illinois governor’s chief of staff, and as a U.S. Navy Reserve intelligence officer. @rich_goldberg